Pro › NFL › Analyst · Week 12

Analyst · Week 12

The stats model is the foundation. This layer reads the week's news and forecasts, reports only what the model is not already counting, and moves the number by a capped amount — every claim linked to its source, every claim graded after the final.

W1W2W3W4W5W6W7W8W9W10W11W12 21,878 news items · latest Nov 22, 6:48 AM ET · cap ±10 pts per game

Is the news layer helping?

Since the layer went live, over 403 graded claims:
  • The adjusted forecast has been worse than the stats model alone — net change in squared error (Brier) of +0.121, where negative is better.
  • 202 of 403 claims pushed the number toward the actual result.
  • It changed the final pick in 5 games, and those flips went 4–1.
This is the whole test. News can't be backtested the way the base model was (2010–25), so the layer earns its place only forward, and only if it lowers the error over many games — not on any one result. Its job is to move the number toward the truth, not to rescue a pick: when it cut a heavy home pick by 10 points and the team still lost, the move was correct (it lowered the error) even though the pick was wrong — the base model had simply started too far above the market. Picks where we disagree with the market's final price are our weaker spot (about 44% in the backtest, versus 68% when we agree) — they're flagged “we differ” on the picks table so you can watch them.

Tune-up, Nov 10, 2026: what we switched off

These claim types made the forecast worse this season (positive Brier change in the scorecard below), so from Nov 10, 2026 they are still read and graded but no longer move the number: key starter out, not on the injury report; key starter returning; other (in-week, concrete, high confidence only); suspension; locker-room or organizational turmoil. Past picks are not changed.
Same 148 graded gamesRecordBrier (lower is better)
Stats model alone100–480.2093
As published (every type)103–450.2105
Without the switched-off types101–470.2081
A replay with the same stored claims and the same caps, those types left out (4 picks would have changed). It is a look back, not a promise: the switched-off types keep being graded and come back if they start lowering the error.

What we do with the news, step by step

This page is the news layer's public notebook. In plain terms:
  1. Before kickoff, every run pulls the feeds and attaches new items to the games they concern. Items published after a game has started are never read: in-game news is not a prediction input.
  2. The reader turns new items into claims: a type (QB change, key starter out, resting starters…), a team, a player, a direction, and a confidence.
  3. The filters decide, in the same run, whether a claim is applied or declined. Declined if it is below the confidence floor for its type, if the model already counts it (the player is on the injury report, the QB is already the named starter), or if it is the kind of story that has no place (offseason hires, turf, "limited in practice").
  4. Applied claims move the probability right then, by a fixed number of points for the type, scaled by confidence, capped. That adjusted number is the pick. "Model 74% → analyst 76%" on a game below means exactly that.
  5. After the final, every claim is graded, applied or declined: did it point the right way, and did it lower the error? Declined claims are graded as if they had been applied, so we learn whether the filter was right to say no.
  6. Once a month, with enough graded cases, the rules change for future weeks: a type that keeps hurting loses weight; a rejection reason that keeps "would have helped" gets loosened. Past picks are never touched. Every rule change is dated in the changelog.
A claim only affects the game it is attached to. It does not carry into next week's model: a starter who misses Week 2 is caught by the injury report by then, and the model counts him there.

How it works

Sources: public news feeds; the National Weather Service forecast at kickoff for outdoor stadiums; the nflverse injury report and named starters are what the model already counts. The reader (one language-model call per game, only when there is new news) returns typed claims about things not already counted. A fixed table turns each claim into points, scaled by the reader's confidence, capped per type and ±10 in total. Weather is logged at zero weight until a season of grading says otherwise.
Claim typeMax points
starting QB change not yet in the feed6.0
key starter out, not on the injury report2.0
key starter returning1.5
resting starters / playing backups8.0
suspension2.0
coaching change2.0
motivation / eliminated / nothing to play for1.5
locker-room or organizational turmoil1.0
unusual travel or schedule disruption1.0
weather at kickoff (logged, zero weight)0.0
other (in-week, concrete, high confidence only)0.5

Scorecard by claim type

After each final: did the move go the right way, and did it lower the squared error (Brier)? Negative Brier change is good. Types that don't earn their weight get zeroed at season's end.
TypeClaimsGradedAvg ptsHelpedBrier Δ
key starter out, not on the injury report2542281.8 111/228+0.240
other (in-week, concrete, high confidence only)85780.4 40/78+0.032
motivation / eliminated / nothing to play for34311.1 18/31+0.008
starting QB change not yet in the feed28275.2 16/27-0.159
locker-room or organizational turmoil15110.8 5/11+0.026
unusual travel or schedule disruption14120.8 6/12-0.005
coaching change761.7 5/6-0.041
weather at kickoff (logged, zero weight)550.0 0/5+0.000
suspension441.9 1/4+0.014
key starter returning111.1 0/1+0.006

Shadow scorecard — what we declined

Rejected claims are kept at zero weight and graded as if applied. If a rejection reason keeps "helping", the rule is too strict; if "other" keeps hurting, it stays out. This is how the layer learns.
Rejected becauseTypeClaimsGradedWould have helpedBrier Δ if applied
no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')key player out341307 150/307+0.191
retired: now on the injury reportkey player out208196 100/196+0.060
return of a player the model was not counting outkey player back163147 84/147-0.115
confidence 0.75 below floor for otherother8777 37/77+0.021
no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')QB change7969 34/69+0.442
confidence 0.65 below floor for otherother3936 19/36-0.009
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)key player out3732 17/32+0.067
soft status (limited/questionable/cleared)key player back2825 16/25-0.036
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)QB change2625 19/25-0.491
already on the injury reportkey player out2222 11/22+0.090
confidence 0.70 below floor for otherother2220 10/20+0.004
confidence 0.30 below floor for key player outkey player out2119 10/19+0.000
confidence 0.65 below floor for motivationmotivation1716 7/16+0.010
confidence 0.75 below floor for turmoilturmoil1717 8/17+0.036
confidence 0.40 below floor for key player outkey player out1513 4/13+0.027
confidence 0.70 below floor for turmoilturmoil1513 6/13+0.022
no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')suspension1413 4/13+0.084
about an earlier game, not this onekey player out1310 6/10-0.019
confidence 0.45 below floor for key player outkey player out1212 7/12-0.018
confidence 0.60 below floor for otherother1211 7/11-0.004
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)other1211 8/11-0.016
not an in-week coaching changecoaching change1110 7/10-0.050
QB out: the model already uses the named starterkey player out1010 5/10+0.036
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)travel105 3/5-0.010
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)turmoil95 4/5-0.010
confidence 0.65 below floor for traveltravel87 3/7+0.009
confidence 0.35 below floor for key player outkey player out77 2/7+0.011
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out77 0/7+0.087
QB is already the named starterQB change66 3/6+0.070
confidence 0.00 below floor for key player outkey player out66 0/6+0.000
retired: schedule feed now names this QBQB change65 3/5-0.023
confidence 0.60 below floor for turmoilturmoil55 3/5+0.002
confidence 0.65 below floor for coaching changecoaching change54 3/4-0.017
offseason / logistics story, already countedmotivation55 1/5+0.039
offseason / logistics story, already countedother54 1/4+0.004
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)motivation55 3/5+0.009
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out55 5/5-0.088
confidence 0.55 below floor for otherother33 2/3-0.004
confidence 0.60 below floor for coaching changecoaching change33 1/3+0.009
confidence 0.60 below floor for motivationmotivation33 2/3-0.014
confidence 0.65 below floor for turmoilturmoil32 2/2-0.013
retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)coaching change30 ––
retired: same player already counted in this gameother33 3/3-0.016
confidence 0.00 below floor for QB changeQB change22 0/2+0.000
confidence 0.30 below floor for QB changeQB change21 0/1+0.015
confidence 0.50 below floor for otherother22 1/2-0.000
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out22 2/2-0.067
retired: same player already counted in this gameother22 0/2+0.006
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out22 2/2-0.034
retired: same player already counted in this gameother22 0/2+0.011
retired: same player already counted in this gameturmoil22 2/2-0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gameother22 0/2+0.005
retired: same player already counted in this gameother20 ––
confidence 0.00 below floor for coaching changecoaching change11 0/1+0.000
confidence 0.25 below floor for key player outkey player out10 ––
confidence 0.30 below floor for otherother11 0/1+0.002
confidence 0.50 below floor for turmoilturmoil11 0/1+0.003
confidence 0.55 below floor for motivationmotivation11 1/1-0.009
confidence 0.55 below floor for turmoilturmoil11 1/1-0.006
confidence 0.60 below floor for traveltravel11 1/1-0.005
offseason / logistics story, already countedcoaching change11 1/1-0.010
retired: same player already counted in this gameturmoil11 0/1+0.014
retired: same player already counted in this gamesuspension11 0/1+0.008
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 0/1+0.008
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 0/1+0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 0/1+0.024
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.006
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 0/1+0.004
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.003
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.018
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.018
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.001
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.002
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.002
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.006
retired: same player already counted in this gameQB change11 1/1-0.030
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.011
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.003
retired: same player already counted in this gameQB change11 1/1-0.029
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.002
retired: same player already counted in this gamemotivation11 1/1-0.008
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.003
retired: same player already counted in this gameQB change11 1/1-0.020
retired: same player already counted in this gameQB change11 1/1-0.020
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.008
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.019
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.003
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.003
retired: same player already counted in this gameother11 1/1-0.001
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 0/1+0.007
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.013
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 1/1-0.013
retired: same player already counted in this gamekey player out11 0/1+0.015
retired: same player already counted in this gamesuspension10 ––
retired: same player already counted in this gameturmoil10 ––
Season: stats model 100–48, model + analyst 103–45; 117 games moved, 5 picks flipped (4 won).

GB @ LA Wed 8:00 PM

est. model 74% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
WR ruled out for season following knee surgery; 4-5 month recovery
LAPuka Nacua 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
Center placed on IR with hamstring injury, out 4-6 weeks
LAColeman Shelton 0.95-1.9 after the final
suspension declined: retired: same player already counted in this game
Three-game suspension for personal conduct violation; serving suspension while on IR, eligible to return after Week 14 vs 49ers
LAPuka Nacua 0.95-1.9 after the final
suspension declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Three-game suspension for personal conduct policy violation; suspension served during IR stint, eligible to return after Week 14 vs 49ers
LAPuka Nacua 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Rams starting center out 4-6 weeks with hamstring strain
LAColeman Shelton 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter returning declined: return of a player the model was not counting out
Edge rusher Micah Parsons confirmed to return Week 12 vs Rams after reconstructive knee surgery
GBMicah Parsons 0.95-1.4 after the final
key starter returning declined: return of a player the model was not counting out
DT set to return after bye week for Week 12 game vs Packers
LAKobie Turner 0.90+1.4 after the final
2 other items read and graded, not shown (we publish roster and schedule facts only).

CHI @ DET Thu 1:00 PM

est. model 66% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
Center placed on injured reserve; ineligible to return until Week 15 at earliest
DETCade Mays 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
Defensive end suffered torn ACL while celebrating sack; season-ending injury
DETAidan Hutchinson 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter returning declined: return of a player the model was not counting out
Safety expected to return this week after missing entire season with knee injury
DETKerby Joseph 0.90+1.4 after the final

PHI @ DAL Thu 4:30 PM

est. model 75% home · no adjustment · forecast at kickoff: 56.0°F, wind 5.0 mph, Mostly Sunny
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
CB placed on injured reserve with ankle injury from 49ers game
DALDaRon Bland 0.95-1.9 after the final
coaching change declined: retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)
Mike Pettine takes over defensive play-calling from Christian Parker; Parker remains DC in title only
DAL 0.70-1.4 after the final
coaching change declined: retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)
Mike Pettine takes over defensive play-calling duties from Christian Parker (remains DC in title only)
DAL 0.70-1.4 after the final
coaching change declined: retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)
Mike Pettine takes over defensive play-calling from Christian Parker; Parker remains DC in title only
DAL 0.70-1.4 after the final
3 other items read and graded, not shown (we publish roster and schedule facts only).

KC @ BUF Thu 8:20 PM

est. model 69% home · no adjustment · forecast at kickoff: 39.0°F, wind 5.0 mph, Rain Showers Likely
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: about an earlier game, not this one
Offensive lineman ruled out for Week 11 vs. Bills
KCJaylon Moore 0.95+1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: about an earlier game, not this one
Offensive lineman ruled out for Week 11 vs. Bills
KCTrey Smith 0.95+1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: about an earlier game, not this one
Running back ruled out for Week 11 vs. Bills
KCKenneth Walker 0.95+1.9 after the final

DEN @ PIT Fri 3:00 PM

est. model 46% home · no adjustment · forecast at kickoff: 45.0°F, wind 13.0 mph, Slight Chance Light Rain
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
Left guard dislocated ankle in Week 10 loss to Bengals, out for season
PITMason McCormick 0.95-1.9 after the final

NO @ CIN Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 85% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: retired: read before this team's previous game (old news)
Guard ruled out for Monday night game
CINDalton Risner 0.95-1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Bengals rule out starting guard Dalton Risner for Monday night
CINDalton Risner 0.95-1.9 after the final

BAL @ HOU Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 77% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
DE carted off with serious leg injury on opening kickoff vs. Colts; status for Ravens game unclear
HOUChris Braswell 0.75-1.5 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
WR injured hip vs. Colts, unable to return; status for Ravens game unclear
HOUKayshon Boutte 0.65-1.3 after the final

NYG @ IND Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 43% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
starting QB change not yet in the feed declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Colts released Daniel Jones on Nov 20; Anthony Richardson now confirmed starter
IND 0.85-5.1 after the final

NYJ @ MIA Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 57% home · no adjustment
No claims shown: nothing concrete in the news beyond what the model already counts.

ATL @ MIN Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 76% home · no adjustment
No claims shown: nothing concrete in the news beyond what the model already counts.

TEN @ JAX Sun 1:00 PM

est. model 91% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
Running back placed on injured reserve
TENTyjae Spears 0.95+1.9 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Edge defender hospitalized after serious car accident Friday night in Tampa; status unclear for Sunday game
TENJaylen Harrell 0.75+1.5 after the final
3 other items read and graded, not shown (we publish roster and schedule facts only).

NE @ LAC Sun 4:05 PM

est. model 35% home → analyst 40% (+5.7 pts)
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
starting QB change not yet in the feed
Drake Maye ruled out indefinitely with fractured fibula; backup QB needed for Week 12 vs LAC
NE 0.95+5.7 after the final
key starter out, not on the injury report graded, not applied (type switched off)
WR expected to miss multiple weeks with hamstring injury
NEA.J. Brown 0.90+1.8 after the final

WAS @ ARI Sun 4:25 PM

est. model 38% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
starting QB change not yet in the feed declined: no ruled-out language (practice status is not 'out')
Gardner Minshew replaced by Josh Johnson (40-year-old, 15th team in career) due to Carson Beck back spasms; fourth starting QB in four weeks
ARIJosh Johnson 0.95-5.7 after the final

SEA @ SF Sun 4:25 PM

est. model 60% home · no adjustment
ClaimTeamPlayerConf.Points (home)Graded
key starter returning declined: soft status (limited/questionable/cleared)
WR set for return Sunday after Achilles injury (last played Week 6); listed questionable but optimism growing
SFMike Evans 0.75+1.1 after the final

LV @ CLE Sun 8:20 PM

est. model 74% home · no adjustment
No claims shown: nothing concrete in the news beyond what the model already counts.

CAR @ TB Mon 8:15 PM

no prediction stored yet
No claims shown: nothing concrete in the news beyond what the model already counts.

Follow your team. It's free.

Your team on top of every page, with its next game and our pick. Want more? Plus from US$7/mo, 7 days free.